Before we get into how to choose a new mattress we should ask a more pertinent question: why buy a new mattress. A few of you reading this will be here because your mattress is broken, lumpy or has a worrying smell.
There’s probably a few of you as well who need a new mattress without knowing that you need one. A recent study tested a group of patients who had difficulty sleeping well, high levels of stress or pre-existing back pain.
The group spent 28 days on their own mattresses before switching to a newer, memory foam mattress. The results showed that patients felt less stress, less back ache and slept better.
Buying a new mattress can be the difference between a good night’s sleep and a bad one. But you don’t have to break the bank to get a decent mattress. Here’s a few tips to help you find the best mattresses under $200.
Best Reviewed Mattresses Under 200
1. Zinus Ultima – Best Cheap Queen Mattress Under 200
Modern mattresses today often arrive with an unwanted odor. This is due to chemical treatments and fire retardants which are common in cheaper products. Zinus stands out because they opt for natural materials where other companies look at synthetics.
The Ultima Sleep Master uses Activ Charcoal and Green Tea extracts to enhance their mattresses. These help to absorb moisture whilst defeating unpleasant aromas. What’s more, this mattress comes with a machine washable outer cover to help protect your investment.
2. Lucid 5” Gel Dual-layered Mattress
This product is aimed at the youth market because its low-profile makes it ideal for bunk-beds. The mattress is a medium-firm although adults over 150llbs will find it too soft. Lucid recommend this mattress for stomach and back sleepers. Side-sleepers will likely need to opt for something plusher.
Most of the mattress is made up from support foam which accounts for the first 5-inches. Laid on top is a 1” thick gel infused memory foam that helps to dissipate heat during the night. The mattress is finished off with a remarkably smooth polyester cover that helps to absorb moisture.
Overall, we felt this could be the perfect product for young children and adolescents. It’s comfortable, offers excellent support and helps to regulate temperature during the night. Adults looking for a bargain mattress may find this too thin and we’d recommend to try before you buy.
3. Best Price Mattress 8-Inch Memory Foam Mattress
Made from three distinct layers this product promises to keep you both cool and comfortable. The 2-inch thick memory foam is relatively standard at this price but still offers good support to your back, neck and shoulders.
The middle layer is comprised of a 2-inch ventilated comfort foam which promotes airflow and keeps you cool during the night. Finally, this mattress is polished off with a 4-inch thick hi-density support base that gives this product a firm feel.
When you’re buying a mattress it’s nice to get a good range of choice. Best Price offer an extra vented version for hot sleepers at the same price, whilst customers can choose between a poly-Jacquard or bamboo based cover
4. Zinus Memory Foam 8 Inch / Deluxe / Cloud-like Mattress, Full
We’ve plumped for the Green Tea 8” mattress which comes in at almost half our budget. You can spend a little more on a 10” or 12” version as well as spending less on a firm 6” version. We felt the 8” offered more than enough comfort thanks to its clever design.
The Green tea mattress uses three basic layers to construct its mattresses. The first is a high density 3.5” support base which adds longevity. The remaining layers are made up of a 1.5” layer of comfort foam and a 1” layer of memory foam which adapts to your sleeping position.
This mattress is an all-rounder that will suit most sleepers. The green tea infusion and Activ Charcoal components will help to keep the mattress smelling fresh all year round. Its CertiPUR-US certified offering great value for money, although hot sleepers might want to look at the more expensive gel version which offers superior airflow.
5. Classic Brands Cool Gel Ventilated Gel Memory Foam 8-Inch Mattress, Twin
This product uses a 2” thick gel infused memory foam to help displace heat during the night. The memory foam aspect reduces pressure points guaranteeing a smooth sleep without troublesome aches or pains. Underneath is a 6” hi-density foam core which is sturdy and durable.
The materials used here are naturally anti-microbial. They also resist dust-mites, germs and allergens. Fresh out of the box there’s no ‘chemically’ smell and the whole unit has been CertiPUR-US certified.
In terms of getting the best bang for your buck, we found the Classic Brands Cool Gel series to be a real contender. The only issue we had was the lack of memory foam. A 2-inch layer is by no means plush and you may want to consider the alternatives if you’re sleeping two people.
6. Signature Sleep Essential 6” Coil Mattress With Memory Foam
The dense inner spring layer is treated with a layer of comfort foam and hi-density support foam. It’s a lot softer than most of the mattresses on our list so if you have pre-existing issues with back pain or other muscular aches you’d be best off buying something firmer.
If you have teenagers this could well be their perfect mattress. Sometimes you just need to get back to basics and this product offers everything you need without a hefty price tag.
Each mattress is manufactured in an environmentally friendly way with no harmful toxins or chemicals. The CertiPUR-US certificate alongside a 10-year warranty is enough to make this 6” coil spring one of the safest purchases on our list.
7. Signature Sleep Contour 8-Inch Independently Encased Coil Mattress
This particular mattress is medium firm. It will help with back pains although, if you suffer from chronic lumbar ache, you’ll need to invest more than $200 to get the support you need.
What we especially liked about this mattress was its lifespan. The individually wrapped coils mean that if one spring gives out it won’t compromise the whole unit. Coming in under $200 with superb manufacture that, if looked after properly, could last up to ten years.
8. Signature Sleep Memoir 10 Inches Memory Foam Mattress, Twin
Suited to sleepers of all types this extra-plush mattress will be especially useful to heavier people or those that roll in the night.
Rated as a medium firm mattress, we found this model to be a little on the firm side at first. This is the best twin mattress set cost less than 200 dollars. That will soften over time and usage whilst the memory foam outer layer keeps things comfortable in spite of its firmness. The materials are CertiPUR-US certified and are put together without leads or phthalates.
9. Englander Finale 10-Inch Innerspring Mattress, Twin
There’s no reason why those who need a coil spring mattress shouldn’t be able to get the same level of comfort for their money. The Brentwood series uses a “Eurotop”, a 4” foam upper that is upholstered onto the sleeping surface.
The Englander Finale is a hybrid mattress that is available for almost half our budget. It offers excellent airflow with great comfort as well. For those with back pains, you might want to look at investing in a mattress with more coils to provide that extra support.
10. Modway Aveline 6″ Gel Infused Memory Foam Twin Mattress
Aveline has been independently tested by US watchdog CertiPUR which means you can rest assured that no harmful phthalates, leads or other harmful toxins. It takes just 2 to 4 hours to expand to its full shape out of the box and there’s no noticeable smell.
Situated in the top end of our budget we understand if the Modway Aveline might be a step too far for some readers. For those who are willing to invest at least 200 USD, you’ll find an excellent sleeping surface that has been designed to last.
How To Choose A Good Mattress For Under 200 Dollars
Know Your Needs
The truth is that we all like it a little different. The ideal mattress for a teenage girl is not going to be the same as the ideal mattress for a retired male. If you sleep hot, you’ll need a well-ventilated mattress, likewise, if you suffer from backache you’ll need something medium firm.
Knowing what you like is the first step to finding a good mattress. With just $200 dollars to spend you might feel your options are limited, but we’ve found a range of mattresses to suit every need; so long as you know what your needs are.
Beds have more than one function. Many people use their bed as an additional sitting spot during the morning hours. If that sounds like you then you should be looking at a coil-spring mattress. These offer much firmer edges than foam which naturally sinks in at the edges.
The plusher the mattress is, the more expensive it will be, so most of our range here are around 6” thick. If you’re over 200llbs you’ll have to invest more in a thicker mattress that will support your weight comfortably.
Sharing your bed with a partner? If one of you likes to roll in the night, then motion transfer is an important consideration. Memory foam mattresses naturally absorb movement which reduces motion transfer and will be your best bet if one of you is a restless sleeper.
During sleeping hours, our bodies are less effective at regulating our temperature. For some people this can cause a restless night. If waking up in a sweat is a regular occurrence for you, then opting for cooling technology like gel layers, or inner spring mattresses will be of benefit.
Benefits Of Memory Foam
Memory foam mattresses adapt to the contours of your body providing better support to your back, neck and spine. They’re also more comfortable than traditional spring mattresses with less risk of motion transfer. The downside to memory foam is that it retains heat.
Coil Spring Mattresses
Coil-spring mattresses are often cheaper than memory foam. That doesn’t mean they’re a worse option though. There’s more space inside a coil spring mattress which means you’ll get a superior airflow, keeping you cool during the night. At this price, they’re also a lot softer and can often be flipped to maximise lifespan.
Consider Cost Differences In Sizes
Like thickness, mattresses are priced in relation to their size. It makes sense given a King-mattress will take up much more material to produce than a twin. The best way to bag yourself a bargain is by opting for a smaller size from a premium brand. That way you get premium quality without a premium price-tag.
Final Thoughts On Budget Mattresses Under $200
As you can see, shopping on a budget means you’ll have to sacrifice size and depth. If you’re willing to do that there’s some great options on offer. A lot of the products featured here are regularly included in sale prices so always shop around for the best deal before making a purchase. Always remember to keep in mind the main thing you need (airflow? comfort? support?) and stick to that when you’re making a decision.